UH3 Project: Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER)
Overview
Principal Investigators:
Sponsoring Institution: New York University Grossman School of Medicine
Collaborators:
- Allegheny Health Network
- Baystate Health
- Beaumont Health System
- Brigham and Women’s/DRCI+
- ChristianaCare Health System
- Henry Ford Health System
- Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
- Mayo Clinic Health System
- MD Anderson Cancer Center
- NYU Langone Health
- Ochsner Health System
- The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center
- Penn Medicine: University of Pennsylvania Health System
- Rutgers Health
- UCSF Health (University of California, San Francisco)
- UF Health (University of Florida)
- University of Utah Health
- Yale New Haven Health
NIH Institutes Providing Oversight: National Institute on Aging (NIA)
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03424109
Trial Status: Completed
Trial Summary
Study question and significance: Among individuals 65 years and older in the United States, half visited the emergency department during the last month of life, and three-quarters visited the emergency department during the 6 months before death. The emergency department offers an opportunity to initiate primary palliative care for older adults with serious, lifelimiting illness. Consultation with palliative care specialists is not always available in emergency departments (typically Monday through Friday during business hours), and emergency clinicians may lack the training or tools to assist older adults who have serious, life-limiting illness in making complex medical decisions. This study aimed to assess the effect of a multicomponent intervention to initiate primary palliative care in the emergency department on hospital admission in older adults with serious, life-limiting illness.
Design and setting: Stepped-wedge, cluster randomized clinical trial including patients aged 66 years or older who visited 1 of 29 emergency departments across the United States between May 2018 and December 2022, had 12 months of prior Medicare enrollment, and had a Gagne comorbidity score greater than 6, representing a risk of short-term mortality greater than 30%. Nursing home patients were excluded.
Intervention and methods: Participating emergency departments implemented a multicomponent intervention that included (1) evidence-based multidisciplinary education; (2) simulation-based workshops on serious illness communication; (3) clinical decision support; and (4) audit and feedback for emergency department clinical staff. The primary outcome was hospital admission and the secondary outcomes included subsequent healthcare use and survival.
Findings: Over the course of the intervention, 807 emergency medicine providers (physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners) and more than 2082 emergency medicine nurses received end-of-life/goals of care communication skills training. There were 98,922 initial emergency department visits during the study period. There was no difference in the rate of hospital admission in older adults with serious, life-limiting illness receiving care before (64.4%) vs after (61.3%) emergency department clinical staff receipt of a multicomponent primary palliative care intervention. There was no difference in the secondary outcomes before vs after the intervention.
Conclusions and relevance: This multicomponent intervention to initiate palliative care in the emergency department did not have an effect on hospital admission, subsequent health care use, or short-term mortality in older adults with serious, life-limiting illness.
Data and Resource Sharing
- MASTER PRIMER SLIDES
PRIM-ER Master Slides
- Protocol_V8
PRIM-ER Protocol (Version 8)
- PRIM-ER Baseline Palliative Care Knowledge Survey_FillablePDF
PRIM-ER Baseline Palliative Care Knowledge Survey
- PRIM-ER Flyer_2021
PRIM-ER Flyer
- EM Talk Handout_SAMPLE
PRIM-ER EM Talk Recruitment Handout
- ELNEC Handout_SAMPLE
PRIM-ER End-of-Life Nursing Education Consortium (ELNEC) Training Recruitment Handout
- ELNEC Course Evaluation
PRIM-ER End-of-Life Nursing Education Consortium (ELNEC) Training Course Evaluation
- CME Evaluation_PRIM-ER
PRIM-ER EM Talk CME Evaluation Form
- PRIMER-main-outcomes_v009
PRIM-ER Analytic Code
- PRIM-ER-2019-UH3 Follow-up
PRIM-ER-Ethics and Regulatory UH3 Follow-up
Featured Interviews
Dr. Grudzen discusses PRIM-ER, a NIH Collaboratory Trial that will implement primary palliative care in emergency medicine across a diverse group of Emergency Departments.
News and Interviews
- News_A Year of Trial Results and Innovations From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
December 15, 2025: A Year of Trial Results and Innovations From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
- News_Goals-of-Care Conversations Affect Emergency Department Care in PRIM-ER Substudy
November 26, 2025: Goals-of-Care Conversations Affect Emergency Department Care in PRIM-ER Substudy
- News_PRIM-ER Team Observes More Healthy Days at Home for Patients With Cancer Diagnosis
July 8, 2025: PRIM-ER Team Observes More Healthy Days at Home for Patients With Cancer Diagnosis
- News_PRIM-ER Team Develops Innovative Statistical Techniques for Stepped-Wedge Trials
March 4, 2025: PRIM-ER Team Develops Innovative Statistical Techniques for Stepped-Wedge Trials
- News_In PRIM-ER Trial, Palliative Care Training in Emergency Departments Did Not Reduce Hospital Admissions
January 21, 2025: In PRIM-ER Trial, Palliative Care Training in Emergency Departments Did Not Reduce Hospital Admissions
- News_A Year of Innovations and Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
December 12, 2024: A Year of Innovations and Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
- News_In PRIM-ER Qualitative Study, EM Talk Program Improved Serious Illness Conversation Skills
February 26, 2024: In PRIM-ER Qualitative Study, EM Talk Program Improved Serious Illness Conversation Skills
- News_A Year of New Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
December 12, 2023: A Year of New Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
- News_Wealth of New Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
December 13, 2022: In Our Tenth Year, a Wealth of New Insights From the NIH Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
- News_Pragmatic Trials in Emergency Medicine
July 18, 2022: New Article Offers Recommendations for Pragmatic Trials in Emergency Medicine
Publications
- Grudzen et al JAMA 2025b
Palliative care in the emergency department—Reply
- Murray et al Intern Emerg Med 2025
Effect of a multi-component palliative care intervention on goals of care discussions for critical patients in the emergency department
- Adeyemi et al BMC Geriatr 2025
Healthy days at home and prognosis of older adults with cancer and non-cancer serious life-limiting illnesses
- Adeyemi et al J Pain Symptom Manage 2025
Acute care use and prognosis in older adults presenting to the emergency department
- Wu et al Stat Med 2025
Bayesian hierarchical penalized spline models for immediate and time-varying intervention effects in stepped wedge cluster randomized trials
- Grudzen et al JAMA 2025
PRIM-ER Main Outcome Paper
- Adeyemi et al BMC Palliat Care 2024
Serious illness communication skills training for emergency physicians and advanced practice providers: a multi-method assessment of the reach and effectiveness of the intervention
- Adeyemi et al J Emerg Nurs
Emergency nurses' perceived barriers and solutions to engaging patients with life-limiting illnesses in serious illness conversations: a United States multicenter mixed-method analysis
- Boyd et al J Am Med Inform Assoc 2023
Potential bias and lack of generalizability in electronic health record data: reflections on health equity from the National Institutes of Health Pragmatic Trials Collaboratory
- Adeyemi et al J Palliat Med 2023
Emergency providers' knowledge and attitudes toward hospice and palliative care: a cross-sectional analysis across 35 emergency departments in the United States
- Tan et al Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2022
Leveraging emergency department information systems to address palliative care needs of ED patients during the COVID pandemic
- Hill et al Glob Adv Health Med 2022
Household income and older adult population predict number of integrative medicine providers around US hospitals: an environmental scan study
- Grudzen et al Emerg Cancer Care 2022
Palliative care models for patients living with advanced cancer: a narrative review for the emergency department clinician
- Hill et al PLoS One 2022
Emergency provider perspectives on facilitators and barriers to home and community services for older adults with serious life limiting illness: a qualitative study
- Gettel et al Acad Emerg Med 2022
Pragmatic clinical trial design in emergency medicine: study considerations and design types
- Adeyemi et al Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2022
Knowledge and attitudes toward hospice and palliative care: instrument validation among emergency providers
- Hill et al J Am Geriatr Soc 2022
Emergency and post-emergency care of older adults with Alzheimer's disease/Alzheimer's disease related dementias
- Rege et al J Pain Symptom Manage 2022
Arranging hospice care from the emergency department: a single center retrospective study
- Pyles et al J Pain Symptom Manage 2021
Locating advance care planning documents in the electronic health record during emergency care
- Richesson et al J Am Med Inform Assoc 2021
Enhancing the use of EHR systems for pragmatic embedded research: lessons from the NIH Health Care Systems Research Collaboratory
- Chung et al J Gen Intern Med 2020
Effectiveness and reach of the Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER) Pilot Study: a qualitative analysis
- Living Textbook Chapter_Clinical Decision Support
Living Textbook Chapter: Clinical Decision Support
- Living Textbook Chapter_Which PCTs Should Have a DMC
Living Textbook Chapter: Which Pragmatic Trials Should Have a DSMB?
- Living Textbook_The Embedded Pragmatic Trials Ecosystem
Living Textbook: The Embedded Pragmatic Clinical Trial Ecosystem
- Hill et al Contemp Clin Trials Commun 2020
Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER): applying form and function to a theory-based complex intervention
- Hill et all Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2020
Access to home and community health services for older adults with serious, life-limiting illness: a study protocol
- Living Textbook Chapter_Monitoring Intervention and Fidelity Adaptions
Living Textbook Chapter: Monitoring Intervention and Fidelity Adaptions: Intervention Adaptation Strategies and Examples
- Tan et al BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2020
Design and implementation of a clinical decision support tool for Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER)
- Grudzen et al BMJ Open 2019
PRIM-ER Study Design Paper
- PRIM-ER Study Snapshot
PRIM-ER Study Snapshot
Presentations
- primer.saem Yamarik 17May20241
Evaluation of a Clinical Decision Support Tool for Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER) Using the RE-AIM Framework: A Mixed-Methods Study
- CCCI 1 year meeting_CRGrudzen 07Nov20241
Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center- Corita R. Grudzen portfolio
- 00_Lightning Round_combined_FINAL
Lightning Round: NIH Collaboratory Trial Results
- 00_Simon_P Values_Approved_combined_DONE
Significance in ePCTs: P Values vs Decision-Maker Perspectives
- SC-Mtg-2024-Day2-Marsolo
Data Extraction and Quality Challenges/ Lessons Learned
- SC-Mtg-2024-Day2-Bosworth
Planning Effectively for Posttrial Activities
- PopHealthResSem_MSK_CRG_111222
The Palliation of Emergency Medicine
- Presentation PRIM-ER 2022 Regina Kaur
Palliative Care in Emergency Medicine
- Gettel - SAEM22
Pragmatic clinical trial design: experience, advice, and key decision points to consider
- Environmental Scan Poster Presentation AcademyHealth 2021
Environmental Scan of Emergency Department Referral Services for End-of-Life Care
- A. Schmucker AGS Presentation Slides
Care Trajectories of Older Adults with Alzheimer Disease in the Emergency Setting
- SAEM_EDPC_Didactic05032021_Tan
Palliative Care During COVID: Innovations in Care Delivery
- The Palliation of Emergency Medicine_Grudzen
The Palliation of Emergency Medicine
- Audit and Feedback Poster_AAHPM2023
The Use of Audit and Feedback in Implementing a Clinical Decision Support Tool Identifying Patients with Life-Limiting Illness in the Emergency Department
- PRIM-ER ELNEC poster_Adeyemi
Emergency Nurses’ Perceived Barriers and Solutions to Engaging Patients with Life-Limiting Illnesses in Serious Illness Conversations: A U.S. Multicenter Mixed-Method Analysis
- PRIM-ER HCSRN_ED identification presentation_2023-02-23
Strategies and Challenges Identifying Emergency Departments within Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Data Warehouse
- AcademyHealth -Adeyemi 06Jun2022
Hospice Referral Proneness Scale: Instrument Validation among Emergency Providers
- saem presentation_baseline data_v3_seun 12May2022
Emergency Provider’s Knowledge, and Attitudes Toward Palliative Care
- SC-Mtg-2023-Day1-Grudzen-PRIM-ER
Corita Grudzen Presentation at 2023 Steering Committee Meeting
- SC-Mtg-2023-Day1-Grudzen
Corita Grudzen Panel Presentation at 2023 Steering Committee Meeting
- AcademyHealth’s 2022 Dissemination and Implementation Science Meeting_Adeyemi
Serious Illness Communication Skills Training For Emergency Physicians and Advanced Practice Providers: A Multi Method Assessment of the Reach And Effectiveness of the Intervention
- GR-Video-01-21-22
Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (GR Video 2022)
- GR-Slides-01-21-22
Primary Palliative Care for Emergency Medicine (GR Slides 2022)
- Access to Home and Community Health Services (APHA 2020)
Access to Home and Community Health Services (APHA 2020)
- Presentation_PRIM-ER_DI_2019_c
Adoption of PRIM-ER: A Mixed-Methods Study Using RE-AIM (D&I 2019)
- PRIM-ER_2019-12-12
Adoption of Primary Palliative Care For Emergency Medicine (PRIM-ER) - A Mixed-Methods Study Using RE-AIM
- Abstract_PRIM-ER_DI_2019_c
Factors That Contribute to Successful Adoption of PRIM-ER: A Mixed-Methods Study Using RE-AIM (D&I 2019)
- Presentation_PRIM-ER_UGM_2019_c
Design and Implementation of a Clinical Decision Support Tool for PRIM-ER (Epic 2019)
- PRIM-ER_2019-08-26
Palliative Care Clinical Decision Support Tool
- SC-2019-UG3-PRIM-ER
UG3 Updates-PRIM-ER